Nathaniel Cornelius Butler

1796 - 1880  (83 years)

• Name	Nathaniel Cornelius Butler
  Birth	25 Jan 1796	Montgomery Co, NC   [1]
  Gender	Male
  Census	1800	Montgomery Co, NC   [2]
  	age < 10(4)
  Moved	Abt 1825
  	To Carroll Co, TN
  Census	1830	Carroll Co, TN   [3]
  	age 30-39(34), spouse age 20-29(31?), 6 children & 2 others
  Moved	Abt 1837
  	To Carroll Co, AR
  Census	1840	Prairie, Carroll Co, AR   [4]
  	age 40-49(44), spouse age 40-49(41), 8 children & 1 other
  Census	1850	Prairie Township, Carroll Co, AR   [5]
  	age 54,wife Anna
  Census	1860	Carroll Co, AR   [6]
  	age 64,wife Amy
  Census	1870	Galena, Stone Co, MO   [7]
  	age 80,wife Emma
  Death	1880	Blue Eye, Stone Co, MO   [1]
  Findagrave.com	21 Jun 2015
  	See Notes
  Burial	Stone Co, MO   [1]
  	Blue Eye Cemetery
  Person ID	I1638	Butler Family Tree
  Last Modified	30 Jul 2026

  
  

  Father	Elias Butler,   b. 1760, Montgomery Co, NC d. Between 06 Mar 1830 and Feb 1838, Carroll Co, TN (Age 70 years)
  Relationship	natural
  Mother	Sarah Elizabeth Stark,   b. 1760, Anson Co, NC d. Bef 1850, Carroll Co, TN (Age < 89 years)
  Relationship	natural
  Marriage	Abt 1778	Anson or Mongomery Co, NC
  Family ID	F195	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  
  

  Family	Amy Arina Ozier-xx,   b. 28 Feb 1799, NC d. 1875, Stone Co, MO (Age 75 years)
  Marriage	1815	Montgomery Co, NC
  Notes	Children: son Martin J Butler 1816 NC - 1867 AR - 1850 census -- supposedly also in Carroll Co, AR son Wilson Sutton Butler 8/23/1819 NC - 12/3/1881 Stone Co, MO - buried - Blue Eye Cemetery, Blue Eye, Stone Co, MO - bef 1843 married Margaret P Dedmon 6/1/1827 GA - 6/17/1887 - ** See their findagrave.com pages ** - 1850 census lists him as age 30,wife Margaret-age 25, 4 children - in Prairie Township, Carroll Co, AR - 1860 census lists him as age 40,wife Margaret-age 33, 9 children - in King's River Township, Carroll Co, AR - 1870 census lists him as age 50,wife Margaretta-age 45, 9 children - in Stone Co, MO - 1880 ceusus lists him as age 61,wife Margaret -age 53, 4 children - in Williams Township, Stone Co, MO dau Margaret Elizabeth Butler 12/21/1859 AR - 9/14/1921 MO - married Rufus Columbus O'Neal 1859 - 1921 dau Temperence O Butler 2/17/1820 NC - 5/18/1892 Afton, Ottawa Co, OK - buried - Wallen Cemetery, Bernice, Delaware Co, OK - bef 1837 married James Dawson 2/28/1813 MO - 4/20/1891 Afton, OK dau Melissa Ann Butler 6/2/1824 NC - 1/21/1865 Freestone Co, TX - on 10/20/1840 married George Washington Baines 12/29/1809 NC - 12/28/1882 Bell Co, TX - son of Thomas Baines and Mary McCoy - ** See their findagrave.com pages later ** - 1850 census lists her as age 26,spouse George W-age 39, 4 children, & Mary Baines-age 66, probably his mother - in Walker Co, TX - 1860 census lists her as age 35,spouse G W-age 49, 6 children, Mary Baynes-age 76, & 2 others - in Anderson, Grimes Co, TX - buried - Fairfield Cemetery, Fairfield, Freestone Co, TX son Alexander Thompson Butler 10/10/1827 Carroll Co, TN - 6/25/1902 both in Huntingdon, Carroll Co, TN - ** See findagrave.com page later -- lists different parents ** *************** - buried - Humbles Cemetery, Carroll Co, TN - on 3/11/1846 married Elizabeth Smith 1824 - 1865 - 1850 census lists him as age 23,wife Elizabeth-age 26, 2 children - in Carroll Co, TN - bef 1867 married Nancy Dickerson - d. 1870 - 4/1870 married Ruth Ann (Sheffield) (Duncan) 1831 TN - 1890 - 1870 census lists him as age 42,wife Rutha-age 37, 8 Butler children & 2 Sheffield children - in Hollowrock, Carroll Co, TN - 1880 census lists him as age 52,wife Ruth A-age 49, 5 Butler children & 1 Sheffield child - in Carroll Co, TN - abt 1890 married Margaret Williams - on 10/27/1896 in Carroll Co, TN married Emma Grizzard 1854 - 1939 - 1900 census lists him as age 72,wife Emman-age 44 - in Carroll Co, TN dau Sarah Elizabeth Butler 1828 Carroll Co, TN son John Quincy Adams Butler 2/9/1831 Carroll Co, TN - 1916 Franks Fittson, Pantotoc Co, OK - buried - Franks Cemetery, Franksl, Pontotoc Co, OK - abt 1850 in Carroll Co, AR married Elizabeth Standlee 3/20/1830 Eureka Springs, Carroll Co, AR - 6/7/1895 Franks Fittson, Pantotoc, OK - ** See their findagrave.com pages ** - 1850 census - age 19 - 1860 census lists him as age 28,wife Elizabeth - in Galesville, Coryelle Co, TX - 1870 census lists him as age 40,wife Elizabeth - in Berryville, Carroll Co, AR - 1880 census lists him as age 46,wife Bettie - in Stephens Co, TX - 1910 census lists him as age 77,widowed,living with dau Susan and William Owens - in Pontotoc Co, OK son Reuben H Butler 1853 Carroll Co, AR dau Susan Adline Butler 12/4/1853 Carroll Co, AR - 6/10/1934 Wilson, Carter Co, OK - on 9/22/1872 in Carroll Co, AR married William Columbus Owens 6/22/1850 Newton Co, MO - 1/17/1911 Centrahoma, Coal Co, OK - buried Franks Cemetery, Stonewall, Pototoc Co, OK son Sam Henry Owens 7/1873 AR - in 1898 married Mollie ??? 11/1881 TX son Neely Owens 11/1874 AR - 1900 Census listed him age 25,widowed dau Rosie Owens 1877 AR dau William Owens 12/1881 AR son John Owens 2/1883 TX son Ben Owens 10/1884 TX dau Amy Owens 12/1891 Indian Territory son Neely Isana Butler 7/17/1856 AR - 2/6/1888 Caddo, TX - married Lucinda M Morgan dau Tenifer Catherine Butler 6/30/1859 TX - nicknamed 'Tempy' dau Amy Elizabeth Butler 1864 TX son John Martin Butler 1866 Carroll Co, AR - 8/6/1961 Pendleton, Umatilla, OR - in 1884 married Marguerette Angie Washburn 3/22/1865 Grayson, TX - on 10/26/1896 in OR married Phoebe L Lemery 3/14/1873 St Louis, Marion Co, OR - 5/17/1947 - ** See their findagrave.com pages ** son Wilson David Butler 1868 AR - bet 1906-1907 Stephens Co, TX, - married Julia ??? son Neely I Butler son Aaron Butler dau America E Butler son Joel Christopher Ozier Butler 1834 Carroll Co, TN - bet 1850-1860 married Mary Jane Donaldson 1836 - dau of Robert Donaldson and Deborah ??? - 1850 census - age 16 - 1860 census lists him as age 25,wife Jane-age 23, 3 children - in Kings River Twp, Carroll Co, AR - 1870 census lists him as age 35,wife Jinsy-age 33, 4 children - in White River Township, Barry Co, MO - 1880 census lists him as age 46,wife Jencie-age 43, 5 children - in Williams Twp, Stone Co, MO son William O Butler 1838 Carroll Co, AR - 1850 census - age 12 - 1860 census - age 21 dau Amy Adline Butler 2/9/1841 Carroll Co, AR - 9/8/1881 - on 7/25/1864 in Laclede, MO mar. Hartwell P Deadman/Dedmon 9/20/1839 Hartville, Wright Co, Mo - 1/5/1922 Seymour, Wright Co., Mo.. - son of Seneca A. Dedman and Obedience A Pool/Pettypool - 1850 census - age 8 - 1860 census - age 19 - 1870 census lists her as age 29,spouse Hartwell-age 30, 3 children, living/working on Guattegin farm - in Hickory, Carroll Co, AR - 1880 census lists her as age 38,spouse H P-age 40, 7 children - in Van Buren Twp, Wright Co, MO - 1900 census - Hartwell listed age 60,widowed, 3 children, 1 dau-law, 3 g-children - in Gasconda Twp, Wright Co, MO - 1910 census - Hartwell listed age 70,widowed, living with son Hartwell A-age 29 & family - in Gasconda Twp, Wright Co, MO - 1920 census - Hartwell listed age 79,widowed,living with dau Dora B Musgrave-age 43 & husband Lemuel H - in Hazelwood Twp, Webster Co, MO son Nealy T Butler 1843 Carroll Co, AR - 1850 census - age 7 - 1860 census - age 18 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ According to WorldConnect: watts_smith Martin J Butler - He died/or was killed in 1867 in AR ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com **** See other entries for James Dawson - mother was a Cherokee ** Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson Birth: Feb. 17, 1820, USA Death: May 18, 1892 Afton Ottawa County Oklahoma, USA Temperance "Tempy" Butler was the daughter of Nathaniel Cornelius "Neely" Butler and Amy Arina Iren'ee Ozier Butler, born on February 17, 1820, per her gravestone, in Carroll County, Tennessee or in North Carolina. Temperance "Tempy" Butler married James Dawson most likely before 1838, the birth year of their first daughter, Ellender (Ellen) Dawson, and maybe as early as 1832 in, perhaps, Berryville, Carroll, Arkansas. James and Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson had three more children. Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson died on May 18, 1892, per her gravestone, in Afton, Ottawa, Oklahoma, IT and is buried with her husband, James Dawson, their son, Wilburn A. Dawson, two grandchildren and a great-grandchild. Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson was my great-great-great-grandmother. Family links: Spouse: James Dawson (1815 - 1891) Children: Ellender Dawson Jackson (1837 - 1924)* Melvina Dawson Low(e) Gardner (1839 - 1923)* Wilburn A. Dawson (1843 - 1899)* Missouri Ann Dawson Graham (1846 - 1916)* *Calculated relationship Burial: Wallen Cemetery Bernice Delaware County Oklahoma, USA Created by: Pam Barns Record added: Sep 27, 2008 Find A Grave Memorial# 30134754 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com James Dawson - 3 findagrave entries - **** mother was a Cherokee Birth: Jan. 27, 1815 Missouri, USA Death: Apr. 20, 1891 Afton Ottawa County Oklahoma, USA James Dawson was the son of Samuel R. Dawson, Sr. and Polly Ann Rogers Dawson, born in Missouri Territory on January 27, 1815, per his gravestone. James Dawson married Temperance Butler most likely before 1838, the birth year of their first daughter, Ellender (Ellen) Dawson, and maybe as early as 1832 in, perhaps, Berryville, Carroll, Arkansas. James and Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson had three more children. James Dawson died on April 20, 1891 in Afton, Ottawa, Oklahoma, IT and is buried with his wife, Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson, their son, Wilburn A. Dawson, two grandchildren and a great-grandchild. James Dawson was my great-great-great-grandfather. Family links: Parents: Samuel Riley Dawson (1782 - 1874) Polly Ann Rogers Dawson (1787 - 1854) Spouse: Temperance Butler Dawson (1820 - 1892)* Children: Ellender Dawson Jackson (1837 - 1924)* Melvina Dawson Low(e) Gardner (1839 - 1923)* Wilburn A. Dawson (1843 - 1899)* Missouri Ann Dawson Graham (1846 - 1916)* *Calculated relationship Burial: Wallen Cemetery Bernice Delaware County Oklahoma, USA Created by: Pam Barns Record added: Sep 27, 2008 Find A Grave Memorial# 30134584 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com James Dawson - 3 findagrave entries - **** mother was a Cherokee Birth: Jan., 1815 Death: Apr. 20, 1891 Husb. of Temperance [Butler] Dawson; parents of 4 ch. Son of Samuel Riley Dawson, Sr. (England) & Polly Ann [Rogers] Dawson(Cherokee ). Burial: Wallen Cemetery Bernice Delaware County Oklahoma, USA Created by: Patricia Mechling Record added: Mar 21, 2001 Find A Grave Memorial# 5307522 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com James Dawson - 3 findagrave entries - **** mother was a Cherokee Birth: Jan. 27, 1815 Missouri, USA Death: Apr. 20, 1891 Afton Ottawa County Oklahoma, USA James Dawson, born in Missouri Territory, was the son of Samuel R. Dawson, Sr. and Polly Ann Rogers Dawson. James Dawson married Temperance "Tempy" Butler, most likely before 1838, the birth year of their first daughter, Ellender (Ellen) Dawson, and maybe as early as 1832 in, perhaps, Berryville, Carroll, Arkansas. James and Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson had three more children. James Dawson died on April 20, 1891 in Afton, Ottawa, Oklahoma, IT and is buried with his wife, Temperance "Tempy" Butler Dawson, their son, Wilburn A. Dawson, two grandchildren and a great-grandchild. James Dawson was my great-great-great-grandfather. ----- NOTES: Birthdate from his gravestone. Other researchers have suggested other birthdates. Family links: Parents: Samuel Riley Dawson (1782 - 1874) Polly Ann Rogers Dawson (1787 - 1854) Spouse: Temperance Butler Dawson (1820 - 1892)* Children: Ellender Dawson Jackson (1837 - 1924)* Melvina Dawson Low/Lowe Gardner (1839 - 1923)* Wilburn A. Dawson (1843 - 1899)* Missouri Ann Dawson Graham (1846 - 1916)* *Calculated relationship Burial: Wallen Cemetery Bernice Delaware County Oklahoma, USA Created by: Pam Barns Record added: Sep 27, 2008 Find A Grave Memorial# 30134584 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ found at http://thelibrary.org/lochist/periodicals/wrv/v5/n8/s75e.html 2. Melissa Ann Butler, born in North Carolina, ca. 1822, married in Carroll County, Arkansas, in October 1840, George Washington Baines, a Baptist minister; this family removed to Texas and were the ancestors of President Lyndon Baines Johnson. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com on 12/31/2015 Melissa Ann Butler Baines Birth: Jun. 2, 1824 North Carolina, USA Death: Jan. 21, 1865 Fairfield Freestone County Texas, USA Married George Washington Baines on 10/20/1840 husband was buried in Saledo TX Great grandmother of President Lyndon Baines Johnson. Daugther of Neely Butler and Amy Arina Ozier Family links: Parents: Nathaniel Cornelius Butler (1796 - 1880) Amy Arina Iren'ee Ogier/Ozier Butler (1799 - 1875) Spouse: George Washington Baines (1809 - 1882)* Children: Thomas Nealy Baines (1841 - 1861)* William Martin Baines (1842 - 1912)* Mary Elizabeth Baines (1845 - 1850)* Joseph Wilson Baines (1846 - 1906)* George Washington Baines (1848 - 1923)* Sibling: Temperance Butler Dawson (1820 - 1892)* Melissa Ann Butler Baines (1824 - 1865) *Calculated relationship Burial: Fairfield Cemetery Fairfield Freestone County Texas, USA Plot: unmarked grave Created by: Harold N. Womble Record added: Nov 13, 2006 Find A Grave Memorial# 16631145 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com - bef 12/31/2015 Melissa Ann Butler Baines Birth: Jun. 2, 1824 Death: Jan. 21, 1865 Family links: Spouse: George Washington Baines (1809 - 1882)* Children: Thomas Nealy Baines (1841 - 1861)* William Martin Baines (1842 - 1912)* George Washington Baines (1848 - 1923)* *Calculated relationship Note: married George Washington Baines on 10/20/1840 husband was buried in Saledo TX Great grandmother of President Lyndon Baines Johnson Burial: Fairfield Cemetery Fairfield Freestone County Texas, USA Plot: unmarked grave Created by: Harold N. Womble Record added: Nov 13, 2006 Find A Grave Memorial# 16631145 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com on 12/31/2015 George Washington Baines Birth: Dec. 29, 1809 Perquimans County North Carolina, USA Death: Dec. 28, 1882 Belton Bell County Texas, USA (1809-1882) Renowned Baptist minister in early Texas history; president from 1861 to 1863 of Baylor University (which included what is now Mary-Hardin-Baylor College); great-grandfather of Lyndon Baines Johnson, 36th president of the United States. Born in North Carolina and reared without formal schooling on a farm, Baines worked his way through the University of Alabama. When licensed to preach at age 25 he became the third generation of his family to enter the ministry. Moved to Texas in 1850. Here his reputation as a wise and peace-loving clergyman continued to grow. He held offices in the Baptist State Convention and founded the Pioneer "Texas Baptist" newspaper, in 1855. When the Civil War broke out in 1861, he accepted the presidency of strife-ridden Baylor University (at Independence) and guided it for two crucial years. Although plagued constantly by ill health, Baines was noted for his stamina. Parishioners also admired his marksmanship as well as his learning. In 1867 he moved to Salado. Preaching and working for Baptist education, he lived there until his death of malarial fever. He is buried in Salado. Twice married, Baines had ten children. (Info from Texas Historical Marker) Family links: Spouses: Melissa Ann Butler Baines (1824 - 1865) Cynthia W Baines (1831 - 1878) Children: Thomas Nealy Baines (1841 - 1861)* William Martin Baines (1842 - 1912)* George Washington Baines (1848 - 1923)* *Calculated relationship Burial: Salado Cemetery Salado Bell County Texas, USA Plot: Old Salado Graveyard, Sect 6d Maintained by: Stephen Peters Originally Created by: Longwired Record added: Jul 13, 2005 Find A Grave Memorial# 11350840 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com Alexander T. Butler ** See different parents listed below *********************** Birth: Oct. 10, 1827 Huntingdon Carroll County Tennessee, USA Death: Jun. 26, 1902 Huntingdon Carroll County Tennessee, USA Alexander T. Butler Burial: Humble's Chapel Cemetery, Carroll Co., Tennessee Military Service: 10 AUG 1862 Enlisted in 7th TN CAV USA Buena Vista, Carroll Co., Tennessee Census: 1850 Carroll Co., Tennessee Occupation: 1850 farmer Reference Number: 551 1850 Census, Carroll Co., Tennessee Butler, Alexander 23 TN farmer Elizabeth 26 wife TN Littlefield 4 son TN Lucy 3 dau TN When a federal unit formed at Huntingdon during the Civil War (7th Tenness ee Cavalry), Alexander joint it and rose to the rank of Corporal in C o. B. According to records, the 7th Cavalry was one of the most unlucky, if not outright incompetent units to fight (the latter perhaps because of poor leadership. After various misadventures, a large part of this unit was captured and some of the men were sent to the infamous Andersonville Prison Camp. The remainder reformed in Kentucky and were assign ed guard duty to keep them out of trouble. Alexander seems to have been among those who went to Andersonville. After the war he received a pension because he was afflicted with pellagra, a disease caused by severe vita min deficiency. He made his living as a farmer in the Dollar community, b ut occasionally peddled medicine in Huntingdon. (notes from R.Allen's webp age) Father: Thomas Butler b: 1802 in North Carolina ********************* Mother: Livinia b: 1796 in North Carolina Marriage 1 Elizabeth Smith b: 1824 in Tennessee Married: 11 March 1846 in Carroll Co., Tennessee Children 1. Littlefield Butler b: 30 NOV 1847 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 2. Lucy Ann Butler b: 15 MAY 1848 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., TN 3. Columbus M. Butler b: 25 MAY 1850 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 4. Fleet Thomas Butler b: 5 MAY 1851 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 5. Artemesia Butler b: 6 AUG 1853 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 6. Annie Elizabeth Butler b: 11 JUL 1855 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 7. Emerson Kent Butler b: 22 AUG 1857 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 8. Newton Munroe Munrow Butler b: 22 OCT 1859 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 9. R.R. Redman Butler b: 6 JAN 1862 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee Marriage 2 Nancy Dickerson Married: 28 JAN 1866 Children 1. Johnny Alexanders Butler b: 1866 in Carroll Co., Tennessee 2. Oder Butler b: 1868 in Carroll Co., Tennessee Marriage 3 Ruth Ann Duncan b: 4 JUN 1830 Married: 30 MAR 1870 Children 1. Miney Ader Minnie Ada Butler b: 27 AUG 1873 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee 2. Susan Gardener Butler b: 21 APR 1874 in Huntingdon, Carroll Co., Tennessee Marriage 4 Margaret Williams Married: 24 DEC 1890 Marriage 5 Emma Grizzard Married: 27 OCT 1896 ======================================== Alexander T. Butler's Bio: 7th Tennessee Calvary, Companies A, B & I, corporal, enlisted for 3 years in Buena Vista, Carroll Co, TN on 8/10/62 and mustered in Benton Co, TN or Huntingdon, TN on 8/17/62 at age 30/32/37 (b. 10/10/1827). Butler furnished his own horse and equipment. He was appointed corporal on 8/18/62. He was one of the 100 or more members of the detachment of the 7th Tennessee stationed at forts along the Tennessee/Mississippi border who went AWOL in June 1863. He either returned to the unit or was captured while AWOL. Butler spent time in Andersonville Prison in Georgia and was exchanged through Savannah, GA in the November/December 1864 exchanges. He mustered out on 6/28/65 due to disability. He was given transportation from Louisville, KY to Buena Vista, TN. which probably means he spent time in the Jeffersonville, IN hospital because of the scrobutus he contracted in prison. Married to Elizabeth Smith in 1846, it was their son Littlefield who is mentioned in the hospital record as a contact relative. In 1887 Butler was a member of the Isaac R Hawkins Post #58 of the GAR and gave his occupation as farmer. He applied for an invalid pension in 1889 and is buried in the Humble Cemetery in Carroll Co, TN with a military marker. His wife received a widow's pension. =========================================== Family links: Spouses: Elizabeth Smith Butler (1824 - 1865)* Nancy Dickerson Butler (____ - 1870)* Ruth Ann Duncan Sheffield/Sherfield Butler (1830 - 1890)* Emma Grizzard Butler (1854 - 1939)* Children: Littlefield F. Butler (1846 - 1925)* Artemissa May Butler Roberts (1853 - 1941)* Annie Elizabeth Butler Rowland (1855 - 1947)* Newton Monroe/Munroe Butler (1860 - 1937)* John A Butler (1866 - 1943)* Minnie Ada Butler Dickerson (1873 - 1916)* *Calculated relationship Burial: Humbles Cemetery Carroll County Tennessee, USA Created by: Bobby and Carol Babin E... Record added: Apr 07, 2009 Find A Grave Memorial# 35637136 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Obituary Alexander T. Butler, 1902 Alexander Butler Carroll County Democrat, June 27 1902 A.T. Butler Dead After a Long Illness and Much Suffering, He Passes Away A.T. Butler died at his home in Huntington last Wednesday afternoon about 6 o’clock. Mr. Butler had been sick with some chronic ailment for a long time, and his death had been expected for several days. “Uncle Alec,” as he was familiarly called, was about 75 years old, a member of the Baptist church, and a christian man useful in his day. He has many friends and relatives in the county who will regret his death and sympathize with his wife and children in their loss. The burial occurred yesterday at the Humble burying ground after funeral services led by Eld.s Marshall and Newsome Joyner. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to World Connect: peggyseidler ID: I00206 Name: Susan Adeline Butler Sex: F Birth: 4 DEC 1853 in Carroll Co., Arkansas Death: 10 JUN 1934 in Wilson, Carter, Oklahoma Fact 2: She filled out an application for the Indian Roll. Burial: Hewitt Cemetery, Wilson, Carter Co., Oklahoma Census: 1860 Raney? Creek No. 3, Gatesville PO, Coryelle Co., Texas Census: 1870 Prairie Twp., Carroll Co., Arkansas Census: 1880 Justice Precinct Pct. 6, Stephens Co., Texas Census: 1900 Indian Territory Census: 15 APR 1910 Stonewall Twp., Pontotoc Co., Oklahoma Occupation: Indian application rejected Occupation: 31 JAN 1907 Filed Eastern Cherokee Application #16048 Reference Number: 206 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at http://mcclure.freeservers.com/delbcar.htm The 1880 Burnet County, Texas census shows Dellamore B. Cargile, 25, single, working as a farm laborer and his brother John W. Cargile, 30, single, also working as a farm laborer. The brothers were boarding with the Daniel Eldridge family. Delemore married Amy E. Butler on July 22, 1881, in Stephens County, Texas. Amy Butler was born June 8, 1862, in Texas, the daughter of John Quincy Adams Butler and Elizabeth Standlee. John Quincy Butler was born February 9, 1831, in Carroll County, Tennessee and died in 1916, in Pontotoc County, Oklahoma. He served as a private in the 30th Confederate Texas Cavalry in the Civil War. A Confederate headstone marks his gravesite in the Franks Cemetery at Fittstown, Oklahoma. Elizabeth Standlee was born March 20, 1830, in Eureka Springs, Arkansas and died June 7, 1895 in Fittstown, OK. She is buried in Franks Cemetery. Their children included: (1) Reuben Butler, b. abt 1851, AR; (2) Susan A. Butler, b. abt 1854, AR; (3) Nelly Butler, b. abt 1856, AR; (4) Tempy C. Butler, b. abt 1859, TX; (5) Amy E. Butler, b. 1862, TX; (6) John Butler, b. abt 1866, AR and (7) Wilson D. Butler, b. 1869, AR. Delemore and Amy moved to the Indian Territory (Oklahoma) prior to 1892, possibly to be near her parents who were living in Indian Territory at that time. Two of their children were born in Indian Territory/Oklahoma - one in September 1892 and one in August 1895. It appears that Delemore and Amy moved their family to Florida, where they lived from about 1896 until late 1899, at which time they moved back to Texas. Their move to Florida may have been about the time Delemore began preaching. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at http://genforum.genealogy.com/standlee/messages/333.html Karen, I'm not sure if this has anything to do with DNA tests that match Elkin(s)---but here is the Elkin(s) tie that I have on my Boren/Standlee tree. John and Susan Boren Standlee had a daughter whom they named Elizabeth. She was born in 1830 in Eureka Springs, Arkansas (I think these people traveled between Eureka Springs and Berryville quite freely). She died in 1875 in Pontoco, Oklahoma. She married John Quincy Adams Butler (1831-1916). (He was a brother to Nathaniel Cornelius Neely Butler whose daughter Melissa Ann married George Washington Baines---Melissa and G. W. being the great-grandparents of Lyndon Baines Johnson.) John Quincy Adams Butler and Elizabeth Standlee Butler had a daughter named Tennessee Catherine Butler. She was born in 1859 in Lampasas, Texas---died in 1908 in Murry, Oklahoma. (The Butlers were on the Boren wagon train to Bell/Lampasa, Texas, abt. 1856---Isaac Boren Sr. being the wagon train leader and the husband of Mary Belle Queen Cave Boren. Mary Belle's mother was a Butler---a sister to John Quincy Adams Butler and Nathaniel Cornelius Butler.). Tennessee Catherine Butler married Benjamin Thomas Elkins (1851-1908). They had a lot of children. Among them was a Joseph Tom Elkin (1896-1905) and John Eleck Elkin (1881-1965). This may be a situation of no relationship between the Elkin(s) mentioned above and the ones you mentioned---or it may be one of those family connections that last for several generations. Also, I've seen a suggestion on ancestry.com family trees that Elkin(s) might be a shortened form of Elkington or Elkinton. We are looking at the possibility that Mary Stratton Bryan Standlee was a descendant of Enoch and Amy Elkington Stratton.---Judy --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 44. viii. Joel Christopher Ozier, m. Mary Jane Donaldson; b. 1834 TN. 44. Joel Christopher Ozier3 Butler (Neely2, Elias1) married Mary Jane Donaldson, daughter of Robert Donaldson and Deborah (--?--) (at least 5 ch). He was born in 1834 TN. He appeared on the census of 1880 Williams, Stone, MO. Children of Joel Christopher Ozier3 Butler and Mary Jane Donaldson were as follows: i. Susan Cordelia4; m. Allen Justus Hale, son of Turner Ogborn Hale and Sarah Butler, 1872. ii. Malissa; b. 1855 AR. iii. Queen Ellen; b. Dec 1861AR (or b. 1860); m. Joseph R. Brinley 12 Sep 1881 Barry, MO. iv. Grant; b. 1869 MO. Three Grant Butlers are known (2nd is Thomas Grant Butler; third is Ulysses Grant Butler, who stayed in Carroll Co. TN). v. Wilson; b. 1872 MO. Is this Wilson E. who was b. 4 Oct 1872 d. 23 Sep 1962, wife M. Etta _?_ 17 Jan 1878-10 Mar 1905, son Ernest C. 24 Mar 1897-14 Oct 1900, all bur. Blue Eye cem.? vi. Robert; m. Rachel Shook; bur. near Grant's Pass,,, OR; b. 1876 MO. Barbara Carter relates that a contact of hers from OK was told by her grandmother that Robert was not a Butler but was found by Joel Butler's family in an abandoned house; another possibility is that Robert was born out of wedlock to one of Joel's older daughters.39 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at http://boards.ancestry.com/thread.aspx?mv=flat&m=232&p=localities.northam.usa.states.arkansas.counties.carroll Rober Nely Butler vick_k(View posts) Posted: 20 Dec 2000 12:00PM GMT Classification: Query Edited: 28 Jun 2001 5:14AM GMT Surnames: Butler According to my information Robert Nely or Nely Robert Butler or N.R. Butler was born in Carrol Co, in 1875. We are told it was tradition in his family for a mans son to take his dads first name as his middle name, he named his son William Robert Butler. The confusion on which is his first vs his middle name is because I have various documents he signed all three ways listed above. His parents died when he was young and he was raised by a sister into his teens when he ran away and moved to Oregon. The story is that he and his family moved back and forth between Stone and Carroll counties. I have seen the Elias Butler line but can not find a tie in, although I am sure there is a relation because of the family stories that were passed on that I have now found on the net and read! If you have any info on this man please let me know! It would mean the world to my father if I could get him connected to his line! Thankyou Re: Robert Nely Butler b2222b(View posts) Posted: 21 Mar 2011 1:17AM GMT Classification: Query Edited: 21 Mar 2011 1:19AM GMT Surnames: Butler Shook Donaldson Green Ozier Hale Hulsey Brinley Shipman Gaddy It's been about 11 years since the previous post. I have the following info on apparently the same person. There are some questions concerning his parentage. Neely Robert Butler b. ca. 1876 Viola, Stone Co. MO (across the river from Carroll Co. AR), mar. Rachel Shook; he is bur. near Grants Pass, OR. Census records indicate that he is a son of Joel O. Butler (b. 1834 TN, d. aft. 1880) and Mary Jane "Gincy" Donaldson (b. 1837 IN or NC, d. aft 1880); Gincy/Gincie/Gensie/Jennie/etc. are nicknames for Jane. 1880 census Stone Co. MO, Williams township: Joel Buttler 46 TN NC NC, Gencies wife 43 IN TN NC, Malissa dau 25 AR TN IN, Ellen dau 20 AR TN IN, Grant son 11 MO TN IN, Wilson son 8 MO TN IN, Robbert son 4 MO TN IN. Joel O. is sometimes called Joel Christopher Ozier Butler, as he may have been nicknamed "Chris". The middle name "Ozier" is someone's guess based on his mother's surname, but neither Christopher nor Ozier are verified by any known record, so I call him Joel O. He is a son of Neely Butler (1796-1880) and Amy Arina Ozier (1799-1875). Neely is a son of Elias Butler of Montgomery Co. NC and Carroll Co. TN (not AR), as mentioned in the previous post. I call N. R. b. 1876 Neely rather than Nely, since his grandfather is Neely (that's the likely connection). Mary Jane Donaldson is the dau. of Robert Donaldson (b. ca. 1805 TN, d. bef. 1870) and Deborah _?_ (b. ca. 1802, d. ca. 1882 Stone Co. MO). This Robert Donaldson is in the 1840/50/60 censuses of Carroll Co. AR. Deborah Donaldson's will dated 26 Dec 1881 Stone Co. MO, probated 13 Mar 1882; mentions "my children" Susan Shipman, Carline (Caroline?) Hulsey (Hulse/Hulce?), Jonathan Donaldson, $5 each; balance of estate to Lidy Gady (Gaddy) and Jincy Butler (also ch.?). Deborah had an earlier marriage to an unk. Green, by whom she had 2 ch. Lydia (mar. James Gaddy, the "Lidy Gady" in her will) and Terry (in 1850, 1860, and 1870 censuses with Deborah's family, apparently never married). The will doesn't explicitly name Jincy Butler as a daughter, but the 1850 census indicates that this is the case. One source Barbara Carter relates that a contact of hers from OK was told by her grandmother that Robert was not a Butler but was found by Joel Butler's family in an abandoned house; although he is called the son of Joel in the 1880 census, this abandoned house story is also interesting, though it seems a bit far-fetched. Perhaps another possibility is that Robert was born out of wedlock to one of Joel's daughters; since Susan b. 1858 had already mar. Allen Justus Hale in 1876, it would more likely have been Malissa b. 1855 or Queen Ellen (b. 1861, did not marry Joseph Brinley until 1881), both of whom are enum. with Joel in 1880. DNA testing might in the future shed some light on this, especially if descendants of Neely Robert don't match descendants of Joel O. My Butler line does not seem to be related to this one, despite published genealogies to the contrary (DNA testing shows a "no match" between me and a descendant of Neely's son Rev. Martin J. Butler). But I have studied the Elias Butler family quite a bit - see the reports at http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~b2222b/index.htm; these reports are slightly dated - am having software problems preventing updates. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ** See Elias Butler document under Misc-Docs •x. Amy Adeline; m. Hartwell P. Dedman, son of Seneca A. Dedman and Obedience Pool;8 b. 1841 Carroll, AR. She and Amy Arena Butler (below) could be same person? • xi. Amy Arena; b. 1842 AR. She sometimes seen as Anna Arena, but handwriting in 1860 census is most likely Amy rather than Any. She and Amy Adeline Butler could be same person? She appeared on the census of 1860 Carroll, AR with her parents. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/V28K-LNX Amy A. Butler, "Missouri, Marriages, 1750-1920" Name: Hartwell P. Deadman **** Birth Date: Birthplace: Age: Spouse's Name: Amy A. Butler **** Spouse's Birth Date: Spouse's Birthplace: Spouse's Age: Event Date: 25 Jul 1864 **** Event Place: Laclede,Missouri **** Father's Name: Mother's Name: Spouse's Father's Name: Spouse's Mother's Name: Race (Original): Marital Status: Previous Wife's Name: Spouse's Race (Original): Spouse's Marital Status: Spouse's Previous Husband's Name: Indexing Project (Batch) Number: M51529-1 System Origin: Missouri-ODM GS Film number: 944625 Reference ID: ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at http://gw.geneanet.org/edugeek?lang=en;pz=mia+lisa+annalise;nz=walbeck;ocz=0;p=amy+adline;n=butler Amy Adline Butler •Born 9 February 1841 - Carroll, Arkansas, USA •Deceased 8 September 1881 , age at death: 40 years old Parents •Jonathan Nealy Butler 1796-1880 •Amy Anna Irenee Ozier 1799-1875 Spouses and children ?Married 25 July 1864 , Laclede, Missouri, USA, to Hartwell P Dedmon 1839-1922 with ?M Columbus Washington Dedmon 1865-1908 ?F Amy Louise Dedmon 1867- ?M William Newton Dedmon 1869-1939 ?M Seneca N Dedmon 1872-1889 ?M Martin J Dedmon 1874-1899 ?F Beady Dora Dedmon 1876- ?M Austin Henry Dedmon 1879- ?F Adeline Dedmon 1881-1881 Siblings ?M Martin J. Butler 1818-1866 ?M Wilson Sutton Butler 1819-1881 ?M William Sutton Butler 1819-1881 ?M Reuben L Butler 1823-1899 ?F Melissa Ann Butler 1824-1865 ?M Melissa Ann Butler 1824-1865 ?F Temperance Temple Butler 1826-1893 ?M Alexander Thompson Butler 1827-1880 ?F Sarah Elizabeth Butler 1828- •M John Quincy Adams Butler 1831-1916 ?M Joel Christopher Butler 1834-1880 ?M Joel Oliver Butler 1834-1880 ?M William O Butler 1838- ?F Ama Adeline Butler 1841- ?F Anna Arenea Butler 1842- •M Nealy T Butler 1843-1915 Half-siblings On 's side Amy Anna Irenee Ozier 1799-1875 ?with ? ? ?F Sara Butler 1820-1900 ?F Elizabeth A. Butler ca 1861- ?F Sarah J. Butler ca 1862- ?F Amand S. Butler ca 1864- ?F Amy F. Butler ca 1869- ?F Melissa A. Butler ca 1873- ?F Nancy J. Butler ca 1875- Notes Individual Note Residence: [1870] Hickory, Carroll, Arkansas, USA (Source: : - www.ancestry.com - Public Member Trees - Ancestry.com - Name: The Generations Network, Inc.; Location: Provo, UT, USA; Date: 2006; - Ancestry.com, Public Member Trees (Provo, UT, USA, The Generations Network, Inc., 2006 - Database online.) http://trees.ancestry.com/pt/AMTCitationRedir.aspx?tid=12458112&pid=-256284873 1030::2147483647 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at www.myheritageimages.com/.../000105_232767e8c4c3b4op6zkt15.doc? Amy Adline Butler was born 9 FEB 1841 in Carroll Co., Ar., and died 8 SEP 1881. She married Hartwell P. Dedmon, son of Seneca Dedman and Obedience A. Pettypool. He was born 20 SEP 1839 in Hartville, Wright Co., Mo., and died 5 JAN 1922 in Seymour, Wright Co., Mo.. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/K6HK-F2V Hartwell P Dedmon, "United States Veterans Administration Pension Payment Cards, 1907-1933" Name: Hartwell P Dedmon **** Beneficiary's Name: Beneficiary 2 Name: Event Type: Pension Event Date: 1907-1933 Event Place: United States Form Type: Army Invalid **** Death Date: 05 Jan 1922 **** Affiliate Publication Title: Veterans Administration Pension Payment Cards, 1907-1933 Affiliate Publication Number: M850 Affiliate Film Number: 565 GS Film number: 1634600 Digital Folder Number: 004695552 Image Number: 00368 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  Photos » Slide Show		Butler-Alexander-T--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--19020625-TN-Carroll-TS-1
  		Butler-Alexander-T--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--19020625-TN-Carroll-TS-2
  		Butler-Elizabeth-(Standlee)--(Nathaniel-c-Butler)--18950607-OK-Pantotoc-TS-1
  		Butler-Elizabeth-(Standlee)--(Nathaniel-c-Butler)--18950607-OK-Pantotoc-TS-2
  		Butler-John-Martin--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--19610806-OR-Umatilla-TS
  		Butler-John-Quincy-Adams--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--1916-OK-Pantotoc-TS-1
  		Butler-John-Quincy-Adams--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--1916-OK-Pantotoc-TS-2
  		Butler-John-Quincy-Adams--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--1916-OK-Pantotoc-TS-3
  		Butler-Phoebe-(Lemery)--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--19470517-OR-Umatilla-TS-1
  		Butler-Wilson-Sutton-(Margaret-P-(Deadman)--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--MO-Stone-TS
  		Dawson-Tempy-(Butler)--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--18920518-OK-Ottawa-TS
  		O'Neal-Margaret Elizabeth-(Butler)--(Nathaniel-Cornelius-Butler)--09210914-MO-TS
  Family ID	F1038	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
  Last Modified	30 Jul 2026

  
  

• Event Map

  Birth - 25 Jan 1796 - Montgomery Co, NC Census - age < 10(4) - 1800 - Montgomery Co, NC Marriage - 1815 - Montgomery Co, NC Census - age 30-39(34), spouse age 20-29(31?), 6 children & 2 others - 1830 - Carroll Co, TN Census - age 40-49(44), spouse age 40-49(41), 8 children & 1 other - 1840 - Prairie, Carroll Co, AR Census - age 64,wife Amy - 1860 - Carroll Co, AR Census - age 80,wife Emma - 1870 - Galena, Stone Co, MO Death - 1880 - Blue Eye, Stone Co, MO Burial - - Stone Co, MO  = Link to Google Earth

  
  

• Photos » Slide Show		Butler-Alexander-T--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)-3
  		Butler-Alexander-T--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)-2
  		Butler-Alexander-T--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)-1
  		Butler-John-Quincy-Adams--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)
  		Butler-Phoebe-(Lemery)--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)
  		Dedmon-Hartwell-P--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)-pension
  		Butler-Nealy-T--(Nathaniel-C-Butler)--pension

  
  

• Notes

  - ** See marriage notes for list of children ** ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- found at findagrave.com on 6/21/2015 Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler Birth: Jan. 15, 1796 Montgomery County North Carolina, USA Death: 1880 Stone County Missouri, USA Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler was a son of Elias Butler. His mother is believed to be Sarah Elizabeth Starke Butler. He had eleven siblings. Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler married Amy Arina Iren'ee Ogier/Ozier in 1815 or as late as 1818. They had thirteen children. ----- NOTES: Many researchers suggest Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler's name is not his correct name. All doucments that are available show "Nealey" or some variant spelling. No marriage record has been found. Many researchers suggest Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler and Amy Arina Iren'ee Ogier married in Montgomery County, North Carolina, but Amy's parents were established in Charleston, Charleston, South Carolina, when they maried. No burial record has been found. Many researchers suggest Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler is buried in Blue Eye Cemetery. Nathaniel Cornelius "Nealey" Butler was my great-great-great-great-grandfather. If anyone has more/better information, please contact me. Family links: Parents: Thomas Elias Butler (1760 - 1838) Sarah Elizabeth Starke Butler (1760 - 1850) Spouse: Amy Arina Iren'ee Ogier/Ozier Butler (1799 - 1875) Children: Temperance Butler Dawson (1820 - 1892)* Melissa Ann Butler Baines (1824 - 1865)* Siblings: Mary Catherine Butler Queen* Mary Elizabeth Butler McAuley (1791 - ____)* Judith Butler Boyd (1791 - 1870)* John Franklin Butler (1795 - ____)* Nathaniel Cornelius Butler (1796 - 1880) Joshua Daniel Butler (1802 - 1878)* Sarah Elizabeth Butler Bobbitt (1804 - 1881)* *Calculated relationship Burial: Blue Eye Cemetery Blue Eye Stone County Missouri, USA Created by: Pam Barns Record added: Oct 27, 2013 Find A Grave Memorial# 119371723 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  
  

• Sources

  [S25] Findagrave.com. [S2] 1800 United States Federal Census. [S5] 1830 United States Federal Census. [S6] 1840 United States Federal Census. [S7] 1850 United States Federal Census. [S8] 1860 United States Federal Census. [S9] 1870 United States Federal Census.